Stupid pve damage question

MikkyX

So my question may sound stupid, I think I know the answer but I'd like to analyze this more deeply.  

WHICH IS BETTER FOR PVE.  FOR MORE DAMAGE.  LVL 80 RELAMPAGO SET OR LVL 110 mugetsu spirit forged set?

I know 99,99 percent will definately say mugetsu, but what got me thinking to ask is the damage percentage u lose when you switch.  Sure the lvl 80 rel set stats don't even come close to the 110 spirit forged set, but you get 10% dmg from it compared to the mugetsu 110 set which only gives you 7%.  So I'd like to know, in this case, would having the full level 80 rel. set with 10% dmg would that be better or worse than the level 110 set who has better attack, and stats, but only has 7% damage rate.

dionysvs

simple calculation, your phys/kido attack x damage rate you see in formation
do it for both sets, see which is higher

MikkyX

dionysvs replied at 2015-11-5 22:31
simple calculation, your phys/kido attack x damage rate you see in formation
do it for both sets, se ...

I thought damage was after physical or kido attack takes away physical defense or kido.  

Zento-Hazashi

the 3% difference doesn't make up for the fact that the 110 mugetsu set gives more ATK, by a much higher amount

treat damage rate and PHY ATK the same for now unless you want a full explanation on it A.K.A Damage overall

MikkyX

Zento-Hazashi replied at 2015-11-5 22:45
the 3% difference doesn't make up for the fact that the 110 mugetsu set gives more ATK, by a much hi ...

NO not really.  I really only wanted to know which would make me do more damage in pve, that's all.  And if the difference between doing damage with one or the other would be significant.  

By the way, what's the best pve enchant I can do to max my damage in events and balance it out in pvp?  Currenlty I use pierce enchant.  I know soul blade is good too, but what about Crit hit enchant, that gives you 20% crit damage, the one you get in gold enchant.  Is that good for pve too?  Or do you recommend sticking with pierce or rather go for soulblade?

MylarHyrule

test in in ES if you really want to know

dionysvs

MikkyX replied at 2015-11-5 22:41
I thought damage was after physical or kido attack takes away physical defense or kido.

it is but enemy defense isnt gonna change w/e equipment you use

Aristeaus

Zento-Hazashi replied at 2015-11-5 22:45
the 3% difference doesn't make up for the fact that the 110 mugetsu set gives more ATK, by a much hi ...

Physical attack and damage rate are only the same at base damage rate.

Lets say you have 100,000 physical attack.

Adding 10% Physical attack is 110,000.  Adding 10% damage is 110,000.

But if you have 100,000 attack and 200% damage rate.

Adding 10% attack is 110,000 attack = 220,000 damage. Adding 10% damage is 210,000 damage.

Physical attack is vastly more important then damage rate when you start to add up all the different % damage bonus's you actually get ( Mods, talents, bonds, zanpakutos, buffs, gear, and skill modifiers ).

Works the same way with Agility vs. Speed. Both are important, and they both effect one another, but when you have % Speed through various effects, Agility is more important ( mostly just because you can get far more of it, same with physical attack ).

[email protected]

MikkyX replied at 2015-11-6 00:15
NO not really.  I really only wanted to know which would make me do more damage in pve, that's all. ...

if you ve triple crown champion title use soul blade for asualters

MylarHyrule

if your looking at maximizing damage in pve, don't forget your title...